Key points
- Bakom's Teguh Santosa said on 20 November 2026 that Google never named the government as manager or funder of the 19,389 terminated channels; the bulletin indeed names no operator.
- Google's Q3 2026 bulletin says the Indonesia-linked networks shared pro-government content, and the largest one also attacked critics of the government.
- Indonesia-linked terminations, 19,372 channels, exceeded the roughly 14,600 Google linked to China in the same quarter.
- Pro-government Indonesian networks in Google's bulletins rose from 3,598 channels in Q1 and 437 in Q2 to 19,389 in Q3 2026.
Verdict: True, with important context. Bakom spokesman Teguh Santosa is right that Google's bulletin does not name the government, or anyone else, as the operator or funder of the 19,389 YouTube channels it terminated. But the absence of attribution does not clear anyone either: Google's own entries describe Indonesia-linked networks pushing pro-government content and attacking the government's critics, and in July to September 2026 they were the largest set of channels Google linked to any country.
The claim
On Friday, 20 November 2026, the Government Communication Agency (Bakom) rejected public claims that the channels Google removed were a government "buzzer" network. Its spokesman, Teguh Santosa, said Google had never stated the accounts were managed, financed or directed by the Indonesian government, Warta Ekonomi reported.
"Please read the report sentence by sentence. There is not a single word that names the government as manager or funder. The term 'government buzzers' is an interpretation in the public sphere, not a statement from Google," Teguh said. He also said the label "linked to Indonesia" is a geographic marker, and that Google's figure of 19,389 channels comes from a closed automated system that no one can test.
What Google's bulletin says
-
No operator or funder is named. Google's Influence Operations Bulletin Q3 2026, last updated on 30 October 2026, has four entries on Indonesia. Each says only that Google terminated channels "as part of our investigation into coordinated influence operations" and describes the content. None names a government body, company, agency or individual behind the networks. On that point Teguh is correct. (Source: Google)
-
The four entries add up to 19,389 channels. In July Google terminated 6,888 channels "linked to Indonesia" sharing content "supportive of the Indonesian government and its administration", plus 17 multilingual channels supportive of the Indonesian government. In August it terminated 10,134 channels linked to Indonesia whose content was "supportive of the Indonesian government and critical of critics of the Indonesian government". In September it terminated 2,350 more. (Source: Google)
-
It was the biggest country tally in the quarter. By our count of the bulletin's entries, Google terminated 19,372 YouTube channels linked to Indonesia in the quarter, more than the roughly 14,600 it linked to China across its China and PRC entries, and close to half of all YouTube channels listed in the bulletin. (Source: Google)
-
The scale jumped from earlier in the year. Google's Q1 2026 bulletin lists networks totalling 3,598 channels sharing Indonesian-language content supportive of the Indonesian government. Its Q2 2026 bulletin lists 437 such channels, alongside 209 channels in networks critical of the Indonesian government. Google acts against coordinated networks on both sides, but the pro-government networks are far larger. (Sources: Google; Google)
-
Google has conceded its bulletin lacked detail. After meeting Google Indonesia and YouTube Southeast Asia on 19 November, Komdigi said the companies acknowledged the bulletin "had not provided sufficient supporting explanations" and was prone to misinterpretation. Komdigi asked for written details on detection methods, human review and error rates, and whether Google knows if the operators are in Indonesia or abroad. Antara reported that country references in the report indicate where account activity is located or where a network originates. (Sources: Antara English; detikInet)
Context
Bakom's point about attribution is fair. Teguh noted that Google has named operators in the past, such as Russia's Internet Research Agency, and it did not name one here. Teguh also said the government "has never defended" coordinated account networks and wants to know who ordered and funded these channels. Komdigi has asked Google to apply the same detection to networks promoting online gambling and pornography.
But the government's response has so far focused on questioning Google's method rather than on finding out who ran the networks. The Southeast Asia Freedom of Expression Network (SAFEnet) told BBC News Indonesia the scale points to "an orchestrated effort by pro-government actors to manipulate public narratives", while saying it could not identify any flow of government money. The August network's stated aim, criticising the government's critics, matters in a year when SAFEnet and Remotivi documented takedowns of posts critical of officials, most of them at Komdigi's request, according to their findings.
What we don't know
Who created and paid for the channels, whether they are based in Indonesia, how many people watched them and how much of their content was political remain unknown. Google has not answered Komdigi's written questions publicly. We will update this check if Google, Komdigi or Bakom release attribution or methodology details.
Sources
- 1.Warta Ekonomi: 19.389 Kanal YouTube Buzzer Pemerintah Ditutup Google, Ring 1 Prabowo Bereaksi (20 Nov 2026), wartaekonomi.co.id
- 2.Google: Influence Operations Bulletin Q3 2026 (updated 30 Oct 2026), blog.google
- 3.Google: Influence Operations Bulletin Q2 2026, blog.google
- 4.Google: Influence Operations Bulletin Q1 2026, blog.google
- 5.Antara English: Govt seeks YouTube, Google clarity on coordinated influence operations (20 Nov 2026), en.antaranews.com
- 6.detikInet: Hasil Pertemuan Google-Komdigi Soal Penutupan 19 Ribu Kanal YouTube Pro Pemerintah (20 Nov 2026), inet.detik.com
- 7.BBC News Indonesia: Siapa di balik 19.000 kanal YouTube pro-pemerintahan Prabowo yang ditutup Google? (19 Nov 2026), bbc.com
- 8.Katadata: 74% Aduan Konten yang Terkena Takedown Dilakukan Komdigi, Termasuk Soal Karhutla, katadata.co.id




