Key points
- Verdict: partly true.
- 3,963,832 people applied for 250,407 CPNS posts in 2024; a paid remote-access syndicate breached the CAT test in 2021 and 359 participants were disqualified.
- Courts convicted the regents of Pati and Ponorogo in 2026 in cases involving payments for posts.
- In the KPK's 2025 survey, 33% of internal respondents cited closeness to officials in nepotism over promotions and transfers.
- TII found 165 of 562 BUMN commissioner seats held by politicians and volunteers in 2025.
Verdict: partly true. The main entry route to the civil service, the computer assisted test, ranks candidates on scores published in real time, though it has been breached by paid stand-ins. Routes that skip the test, such as honorary hiring, village posts, promotions and state company boards, show documented use of connections and money in court rulings, KPK surveys and watchdog counts.
The claim
"You have to have 'orang dalam' (an insider) to get into a government agency" is a common belief, and it resurfaced in reactions to a viral post on education requirements for officials in November 2026. In a KedaiKOPI online survey of 1,213 people aged 17 to 45 in September 2026, 56% named needing connections or an insider as the main barrier to finding work, the most cited barrier. That survey covered all jobs, not only public ones, and KedaiKOPI said its sample was non-probability.
We checked the claim route by route, because people enter the public sector in several different ways.
The civil service test: scored openly, breached at times
New civil servants (CPNS) are selected through the computer assisted test (CAT) run by the National Civil Service Agency (BKN). In 2024, 3,963,832 people applied for 250,407 posts, about 16 per post. BKN head Zudan Arif Fakrulloh said on 24 September 2026 that the system "cannot be intervened by anyone" because scores appear in real time and "everything is determined by each person's ability".
The official line is not the whole record. Police said in April 2022 that a syndicate used remote access software to answer CAT exams for paying candidates in the 2021 intake, charging Rp150 juta to Rp600 juta; 359 participants were disqualified, and the heads of the civil service agencies of two districts were among those named, Kompas reported. In November 2023 a paid stand-in was caught sitting a CPNS exam for the Attorney General's Office in Lampung, and police named six suspects. These cases show the test can be cheated, but they are breaches that led to disqualification, not evidence that every CPNS place goes to insiders. Nearly four million applicants a year compete through this route.
Routes outside the test: documented insider and paid access
Honorary staff and PPPK. Many public workers started as honorary (honorer) staff hired directly by agencies, later given priority in contract civil servant (PPPK) selection. In Enrekang, South Sulawesi, an inspectorate check of 589 PPPK hired in 2023 found 64 had used fake honorary employment letters, which the district said were allegedly issued by some school and health centre heads; their contracts were ended, detikSulsel reported in August 2025. Commission II deputy chair Bahtra Banong said in December 2024 that some regional civil service agencies manipulated data, shutting out long-serving honorary staff.
Village posts and promotions. Courts have convicted regional heads of selling posts. Pati regent Sudewo was sentenced to 8.5 years on 21 October 2026 in a case that included extortion over 601 village official posts, priced at Rp165 juta to Rp225 juta per candidate according to prosecutors; he said he was considering an appeal. Ponorogo regent Sugiri Sancoko was sentenced to 6.5 years on 14 August 2026, including for taking Rp900 juta to keep a hospital director in post. Earlier, the regents of Klaten, Nganjuk, Probolinggo and Pemalang were convicted of selling or taking money for posts.
What civil servants report. In the KPK's 2025 Integrity Assessment Survey, internal respondents said nepotism in promotions and transfers ran through closeness to officials (33%), kinship (32%) and shared alma mater or organisation (23%). Reported outside influence over hiring of non-civil-servant staff, promotions and transfers in regional governments rose to 20% from 10% a year earlier.
State company boards. Commissioner seats are appointed, not tested. Transparency International Indonesia found 165 of 562 BUMN commissioner posts held by politicians and political volunteers in September 2025, and counted 30 deputy ministers still sitting as commissioners in 2026 despite a Constitutional Court ruling against the practice. Danantara said in August 2025 it had cut boards to at most six members; TII said the number of posts had not fallen.
Our verdict
Partly true. "Must" overstates it for the CPNS test, where millions compete on published scores and proven cheating has led to disqualifications. But for honorary and contract hiring, village posts, promotions and boardroom seats, court verdicts, the KPK's survey of civil servants and TII's counts show that connections and payments do decide who gets in. Our analysis sets out the full data, and a companion fact check looks at degree requirements in job ads.
Sources
- 1.Katadata Databoks: Survei KedaiKOPI hambatan pemuda cari kerja, databoks.katadata.co.id
- 2.BKN: Jumlah pelamar CPNS 2024 capai 3,9 juta, bkn.go.id
- 3.KemenPANRB: Tersedia 250.407 formasi CPNS 2024, menpan.go.id
- 4.BKN: Kepala BKN tegaskan sistem CAT tidak bisa diintervensi, bkn.go.id
- 5.Kompas: Sindikat joki ujian masuk CASN 2021 terbongkar, kompas.id
- 6.Kompas.com: Kasus joki CPNS Kejaksaan di Lampung, regional.kompas.com
- 7.detikSulsel: 64 PPPK Enrekang pakai SK honorer fiktif, detik.com
- 8.DPR: Pimpinan Komisi II ungkap modus manipulasi data PPPK, emedia.dpr.go.id
- 9.Antara: Bupati Pati Sudewa divonis 8,5 tahun, antaranews.com
- 10.BBC News Indonesia: Sudewo divonis 8,5 tahun, bbc.com
- 11.Antara Jatim: Sugiri Sancoko divonis 6,5 tahun, jatim.antaranews.com
- 12.detikJatim: Kepala daerah Jatim ditangkap KPK, detik.com
- 13.detikNews: Bupati Klaten divonis 11 tahun, news.detik.com
- 14.Antara: Bupati Pemalang dihukum 6,5 tahun, antaranews.com
- 15.KPK: Booklet SPI 2025, spi.kpk.go.id
- 16.TI Indonesia: Komisaris rasa politisi, ti.or.id
- 17.TI Indonesia: Dua putusan MK diabaikan, wamen rangkap komisaris, ti.or.id
- 18.Republika: Danantara pangkas komisaris, ekonomi.republika.co.id




